What Was The Most Important Question That Needed To Be Answered at Phillies Instructs?

The final game last week of Phillies Instructs against the Yankees Instructs gave us hope for a better future. But the future is a long way off.  They won the game convincingly, 6-1, but that was not important. What was important that all seven pitchers in the game had “swing and miss” stuff, striking out 14. They had some pop in the lineup. One batter, corner outfielder Ben Akilinski, hit two home runs. The left side of the infield performed credibly with Alec Bohm and Luis Garcia each having base hits. You can read more about the final Instructs game in the previous blog, HERE.

For me, the most important question that needed to be answered in Instructs is this. Do the Phillies have a long term solution at third base and shortstop?  Clearly, both Bohm, the 2018 first round draft pick, and Garcia, the big international signing from 2017, can hit based on what we saw at Instructs games.

Will Alec Bohm and Luis Garcia be the answers on the left side of a future Phillies infield?

It’s clear from the scouting reports over the last few weeks that Luis Garcia will be an elite player in the middle infield. He looked great at both both second and shortstop in the Instructs games we attended.

This is what Ben Badler of Baseball America said in a recent chat and update on the Gulf Coast League:

“The split on Garcia as an amateur was whether you saw him as a top of the order bat or someone who could play shortstop well but would fit better at the bottom of the order. This year, all the reviews I was hearing on his bat were highly encouraging. Good bat control, advanced approach, knows the strike zone, and obviously the performance to go with it as a 17-year-old in that league is impressive. That’s a very well-rounded player, and the chance to be a plus hitter with plus defense at shortstop is really exciting.”

“Garcia is a smooth, graceful defender at shortstop with quick feet, great hands and a plus arm. He has the ability to make the flashy barehanded play, though unlike a lot of young shortstops, Garcia also makes smart decisions in the field and plays under control. While there was a split camp among scouts on Garcia’s hitting ability as an amateur, he showed a mature hitting approach from both sides in the GCL.”

“A solid-average runner, Garcia has a calm, quiet setup and uses his hands well at the plate, staying within the strike zone and spraying line drives around the field with gap power.”

Jim Salisbury, of nbcsports.com.Phildelphia, posted a recent article about Garcia after he was named the top prospect this year in the Gulf Coast League by Baseball America, Read HERE. 

Philly.com’s Bob Brookover in his recent review of the Phillies farm system quotes a scout  as saying Garcia “is going to be a player.”

The verdict on Bohm is not as optimistic on his defense.   We have seem him make a couple of errors at third in Instructs games.

Brookover quoted a scout as saying about Bohm, “most of the time college players come into professional baseball, you don’t see the guy at his best. You’ll see the real guy in 2019. I do not think he will be a third baseman”.

Another infielder gets high grades from a Phillies assistant General Manager, Bryan Minniti. He is Logan Simmons. Minniti said in the Brookover post, “he’s one of the guys you haven’t heard of yet but you will soon”.  Simmons was a sixth round draft pick in the 2018 draft.

Could this be the likely Phillies infield in the next couple of years: Bohm at third, Garcia at short, Scott Kingery at second and Rhys Hoskins at first?  The 2019 season should tell us a lot more.








About Baseball Ross

I have been a faithful Phillies follower all my life. Today I am most intrigued by those players in the minor league system who work every day of the year to make it to the Show. This is what this blog is mostly all about. To read more, click here: https://baseballross.wordpress.com/2012/02/05/how-i-got-started-in-baseball/
This entry was posted in 2018, October and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s